Datenschutzerklärung
Privacy
Who is responsible
Bastian Bolsinger, Am Schönbach 20, 73433 Aalen, Germany, go@noearlierthan.com.
What this site does
No Earlier Than sets no cookies and runs no analytics, ads or trackers. It uses no local storage or other browser storage unless you turn on notifications for a launch (see “Notifications”). Fonts, photos and scripts come from noearlierthan.com itself: your browser contacts no other site unless you follow a link, press play on a webcast, turn on notifications or let it find your location, for which it may use a location service of its own.
Hosting
The site runs on Cloudflare (Cloudflare, Inc., 101 Townsend St., San Francisco, CA 94107, USA). To deliver a page, or a calendar your calendar app refreshes, Cloudflare processes the technical data every request carries: your IP address, the time, the address requested and your browser’s or app’s identification. Cloudflare does this on my behalf under a data processing agreement; for the security and operation of its network it may also process some of this data as a controller of its own, as its privacy policy explains. The data is used to answer the request; I keep no logs of visits and store none of it myself. Cloudflare also shows me anonymous totals of these requests, such as how many reached which page on a day, from which countries and linking sites and from which kinds of browser or calendar app; they name no one, and nothing in the pages collects them. The legal basis is my legitimate interest in delivering the site securely and reliably (Art. 6 (1) (f) GDPR).
Cloudflare may process data in the USA. It takes part in the EU–US Data Privacy Framework, for which the European Commission has decided that the USA ensures an adequate level of protection (Art. 45 GDPR, Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795).
Webcasts
Launch pages can play webcasts from YouTube in the page: the launch provider’s or agency’s own, NASASpaceflight’s, NASASpaceflight’s cameras around the clock at the launch sites and at SpaceX’s engine test site in McGregor, Texas, and the mission’s other coverage, such as its news conferences or the docking at a space station. Until you press a play button, your browser contacts no one but noearlierthan.com. When you press play, the player loads from youtube-nocookie.com, YouTube’s privacy-enhanced mode, and from Google’s servers, run by Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland. YouTube then receives your IP address, this site’s address as referrer, as YouTube requires, and your browser’s technical data, and it may store information on your device. In this mode, Google says, a view is not used to personalize YouTube or advertising; its privacy policy applies. While a live webcast plays, the page reads its playback position from the player, so that the page’s clocks and flight data can show the webcast’s moment, and may play it slightly faster to bring it closer to live; the position stays in your browser and is neither sent to me or anyone else nor stored. The legal basis is your consent, given by pressing play (Art. 6 (1) (a) GDPR, § 25 (1) TDDDG); it covers that playback, and you withdraw it at any time by closing the player or the page (Art. 7 (3) GDPR). Google may process data in the USA and takes part in the EU–US Data Privacy Framework (Art. 45 GDPR, Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795). Webcasts on NASA+ open on its own site.
SpaceX’s own webcasts, which SpaceX broadcasts on X, can also play in the page. Until you press their play button, your browser contacts no one but noearlierthan.com. When you press play, the player loads from studio.x.com and X’s servers, run for people in the European Union by X Internet Unlimited Company, One Cumberland Place, Fenian Street, Dublin 2, D02 AX07, Ireland. X then receives your IP address, this site’s address and your browser’s technical data, and it stores an identifier on your device, a cookie kept for up to 13 months. X keeps information about views of its content on other websites for up to 12 months and may show advertising before a webcast; its privacy policy applies. The legal basis is your consent, given by pressing play (Art. 6 (1) (a) GDPR, § 25 (1) TDDDG); it covers that playback, and you withdraw it at any time by closing the player or the page (Art. 7 (3) GDPR); the cookie stays in your browser until you delete it. X may process data in the USA and takes part in the EU–US Data Privacy Framework (Art. 45 GDPR, Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795).
Your location
The “In orbit now” section can show when the space stations and the other spacecraft on its globe pass over you. Only when you press “Show passes over you” does your browser ask for your permission, and only if you give it does it hand the page an approximate location; how it finds it, from your device’s location services or a service of the browser’s maker, is up to your browser. The page rounds the location to a tenth of a degree, a grid of about 10 km, and uses it on your device only, to mark your place on the globe and to work out the passes. I never receive it: it is not sent to noearlierthan.com or anyone else, not stored and not logged, and it is forgotten when you leave or reload the page. The legal basis is your consent, given by pressing the button and allowing your browser’s request (Art. 6 (1) (a) GDPR, § 25 (1) TDDDG); your browser’s settings take back its permission at any time.
Notifications
A launch page can notify you when the launch gets a new time, holds or stands down, when its webcast starts, when it has flown, when its booster has landed and, for a flight to a space station, when the spacecraft has docked. Only when you press the page’s bell (“Notify me”) does your browser ask for your permission, and only if you allow it does it store two things for this site: a push subscription, issued by the push service your browser uses, and this site’s service worker, a small script that does nothing but show these notifications with the site’s icon and open the launch’s page when you tap one. When you turn them on, a first notification shows that they reach your device.
For each subscription I store its address at the push service (the endpoint), the two keys that encrypt its notifications and the launches it follows, nothing else: no IP address, no other identifier and no logs. They are kept on Cloudflare’s servers in the EU, which run this site on my behalf (see “Hosting”). While a notification is on its way, I also keep which subscriptions it still has to reach and, where a push service asks me to wait, until when; this goes once it has been delivered, is no longer news, or the wait is over.
A notification goes from noearlierthan.com, encrypted, to that push service, which your browser’s maker runs and which delivers it to your device: Apple’s for Safari, Google’s for Chrome and most browsers built on it, Mozilla’s for Firefox, Microsoft’s for Edge. The push service cannot read the notification; it sees the endpoint it issued to your browser, when a notification was sent, its size and how long it may wait for your device. It processes this under its own responsibility and privacy policy and may do so in the USA. Google and Microsoft take part in the EU–US Data Privacy Framework (Art. 45 GDPR, Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795); Apple’s and Mozilla’s privacy policies explain how they protect the data they transfer.
I delete a subscription and its keys as soon as it follows no launch: when you stop notifications, or once the launches it follows have flown and their landings are over, at the latest a day after their time. It follows a flight to a space station until the notification of its docking has gone out, at the latest a day after the docking planned for it and never more than four days after liftoff. One whose push service does not accept that first notification within a quarter of an hour, or later reports it as no longer valid, for example after you withdrew the permission, I delete at once.
To stop, press the bell again (“Stop notifications”) or withdraw the permission in your browser’s or device’s settings. When you stop following your last launch, your browser removes the subscription and the service worker as well; once nothing more is to come for the launches you followed, it removes them the next time you open a page with the bell. The legal basis is your consent, given by pressing the bell and allowing your browser’s request (Art. 6 (1) (a) GDPR, § 25 (1) TDDDG); you may withdraw it at any time (Art. 7 (3) GDPR).
Calendar subscriptions
Your calendar app fetches a subscribed calendar regularly, from every few minutes to about once a day, from your device or from its provider’s servers, for example Apple iCloud or Google. The address carries your device’s time zone for the notes and the alert you picked on the calendar page, and nothing else about you.
If you write to go@noearlierthan.com, your message and address are used to answer you and kept only as long as that takes. The mailbox is hosted by Apple (iCloud Mail). The legal basis is my legitimate interest in answering (Art. 6 (1) (f) GDPR).
No Earlier Than on X
No Earlier Than posts on X as @noearlierthan. If you visit the account, X Internet Unlimited Company (Fenian Street, Dublin 2, D02 AX07, Ireland) processes your data under its own privacy policy, whether you are signed in or not. I see there what anyone sees, and statistics about the account only in aggregate, never who visited. Where X and I are jointly responsible for such statistics (Art. 26 GDPR), you may exercise your rights with either of us; X holds the data. The legal basis for the account is my legitimate interest in reaching people who follow launches where they are (Art. 6 (1) (f) GDPR). X may process data in the USA; its privacy policy explains on what basis.
People named on the site
Crew members appear with their names, roles and portraits as NASA, SpaceX and Launch Library 2 publish them for their missions, and with links to the public profiles that Launch Library 2 or their agency lists for them, since the site reports on these flights (Art. 6 (1) (f) GDPR). A crew member may object at any time at go@noearlierthan.com.
Your rights
You have the right to access, rectification, erasure, restriction of processing, data portability and objection (Art. 15 to 21 GDPR), and to lodge a complaint with a supervisory authority, for example the State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information Baden-Württemberg. Write to go@noearlierthan.com.
Your right to object
Where data is processed on the basis of legitimate interests (Art. 6 (1) (f) GDPR), you may object at any time on grounds relating to your particular situation (Art. 21 GDPR). Write to go@noearlierthan.com.